Table of Contents
Idrissa Gueye’s Early Dismissal in Everton’s Stunning Victory Over Manchester United
In a dramatic twist during Everton’s impressive Premier League triumph at Old Trafford, midfielder Idrissa Gueye was shown a red card just 13 minutes into the match after an altercation with teammate Michael Keane.
The Incident Unfolded
The confrontation began when Gueye miscontrolled a loose ball inside Everton’s penalty area, inadvertently passing it to Keane. Frustrated by the error, Gueye verbally confronted Keane before escalating the situation by striking him across the face. Referee Tony Harrington promptly issued a red card for violent conduct, reducing Everton to ten men early in the game.
Everton’s Resilience and Gueye’s Apology
Despite being a man down, Everton managed to secure a 1-0 victory thanks to Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall’s decisive goal in the 29th minute. Following the match, Gueye expressed remorse both privately and publicly. In an Instagram statement, he said:
“I want to apologise first to my teammate Michael. I take full responsibility for my reaction. I also apologise to my teammates, staff, fans, and the club. This incident does not represent who I am or the values I uphold. Emotions can run high, but nothing justifies such behavior. I will ensure it never happens again.”
Managerial Perspectives: Moyes and Amorim Weigh In
Everton manager David Moyes offered a nuanced view on the incident, suggesting that internal disputes can sometimes fuel team spirit. Speaking to Sky Sports, Moyes remarked:
“If nothing had happened, no one would have been surprised. The referee might have taken more time to consider the decision. The rules are clear: striking a teammate can lead to trouble. But I appreciate players holding each other accountable. It shows toughness and resilience, which are vital for results. While I’m disappointed by the sending off, Gueye has apologized and praised the team’s effort.”
Meanwhile, Manchester United’s head coach Ruben Amorim criticized his own squad for lacking aggression and disagreed with the red card decision:
“Fighting isn’t inherently negative. It means players care and want to avoid conceding goals. I don’t agree with the sending off. I want my players to challenge each other when possession is lost. It’s a sign of commitment, not animosity. We need to improve in this area moving forward.”
Dewsbury-Hall Reflects on the ‘Moment of Madness’
Match-winner Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall described Gueye’s red card as an avoidable lapse in judgment but praised the team’s response:
“We started strong, but that moment was a clear mistake. Idrissa apologized after the game, and that’s all we can ask for. The team’s reaction was outstanding-we could have fallen apart, but instead, we grew stronger. The manager reminded us to stay focused and stick to our plan, which we did in the second half.”
Debate Over the Red Card: Experts and Former Players Weigh In
On Sky Sports commentary, Gary Neville questioned the severity of Gueye’s punishment, pondering whether the slap warranted a straight red:
“Was there enough force in that slap to justify a sending off? It seemed more like a light tap than a serious strike. Perhaps a yellow card would have sufficed.”
Jamie Carragher echoed this sentiment during Monday Night Football, suggesting the referee could have managed the situation more diplomatically:
“Could the referee have calmed things down by speaking to the players instead of immediately resorting to the rulebook? Sometimes managing emotions on the pitch is better than strict enforcement.”
Conversely, former Everton manager and Portugal head coach Roberto Martinez supported the red card decision, emphasizing the rules regarding violent conduct:
“Although it was a misunderstanding, the slap was an act of aggression above the neck, which the laws of the game clearly state must be punished with a red card.”
Premier League Regulations and Suspension Details
According to Premier League guidelines, any deliberate strike to the head or face with the hand or arm constitutes violent conduct unless the contact is deemed negligible. Gueye’s action falls under this category, resulting in a three-match suspension. He will miss the following fixtures:
- Saturday: Newcastle United (Home) – Live on Sky Sports
- December 2: Bournemouth (Away) – Live on Sky Sports
- December 6: Nottingham Forest (Home)
Historical Context: Rare Instances of Players Striking Teammates
Gueye’s red card marks a rare occurrence in Premier League history. The last player to be dismissed for striking a teammate was Ricardo Fuller in 2008 during Stoke City’s match against West Ham. Prior to that, the infamous double sending off of Lee Bowyer and Kieron Dyer in 2005 remains a notable example.
Past Incidents: Bowyer-Dyer and Fuller Cases
Lee Bowyer received a seven-game ban in 2005 after his altercation with teammate Kieron Dyer, including a £30,000 fine. The incident contributed to Bowyer’s eventual transfer to West Ham United. In contrast, Ricardo Fuller’s 2008 sending off for striking captain Andy Griffin was seen as a catalyst for improved team unity, with Fuller stating:
“Sometimes negative moments can bring positive outcomes. It’s done and dusted, and it made us stronger as a team.”
Visual Recap: Gueye’s Controversial Moment
